MEASUREMENT SCIENCE REVIEW 

REVIEWER'S RECOMMENDATION FORM

MSR-Number:


Author(s):


Title:

Dear Reviewer, MEASUREMENT SCIENCE REVIEW has won its position as a high quality international journal. With your help as a referee we will be pleased to confirm and to increase this quality. We are now asking our referees to judge a paper by rigorously implementing the following criteria:

QUALITY: The paper has the highest scientific quality Good quality of the paper, original, internationally competitive Good quality of the paper, recommended as a technical note or a short communication Medium quality, limited interest Low quality, poor work, unsuitable for publishing

QUESTIONS: Does the article have a character of a basic scientific research paper in the “Measurement Science” sphere, (theory, analysis, synthesis, modelling, measurement, new sensors, data processing, data interpretation, graphical evaluation, new results,..)? Yes Partially No

Does the article explain a clear description of what is new, how these results advance the scientific and technological elements of the subject "Measurement Science" ? New information Valuable confirmation of present knowledge Clarity to present understanding New perspective, issue, or problem definition Not much

Do you think this manuscript is of potential interest? Great interest to most readers Interest to most readers Interest to a few readers, scientists in the specific field Little interest to any reader

RECOMMENDATION:
I. TO BE ACCEPTED		a) for publication in present form
		b) with minor amendments
II. TO BE REVISED		a) some points need to be clarified
		b) contains some errors
		c) the title is not adequate and appropriate
		d) diagrams, tables, and captions are not clear
		e) badly written (poor English)
		f) references old and inadequate
		g) too many figures / tables
		h) figures poorly drawn
		i) abstract and conclusion not general enough to be understood by the non-specialists
III. TO BE REJECTED		a) contains basic errors or faulty judgements
		b) not original and important enough
		c) the subject is too far removed from Measurement Science
		d) more suitable for other journal

If you wish, you can use this space for your REPORT to the author(s):

or submit your REPORT on separate file:


Report for editor only:


REVIEWER'S PERSONAL DATA

NAME:
ADDRESS:
E-MAIL:
Please, write this security code into the text field bellow: